The HEART framework revolutionised UX design, however it’s time for an improve.

By now, the HEART framework ought to be recognized to each UX designer, because it reaches near a decade since Kerry Rodden, Hilary Hutchinson, and Xin Fu from Google’s analysis workforce launched the framework to the group.

In a nutshell, the framework contains 5 classes: happiness (H), engagement (E), adoption (A), retention (R), and process success (T), forming the phrase HEART. Every class additionally comes with three parameters: the purpose (G) or goal, the sign (S) or proof of a consumer’s actions, and the quantifiable metrics (M). A UX practitioner then fills within the related info pertaining to the product they’re designing and tracks the outcomes accordingly.

Given its usefulness to assist designers to concentrate on key facets of design objectively, together with its catchy identify, it’s no shock that the HEART framework is a well-liked software amongst designers. And whereas there are numerous different metrics, just like the pirate metrics (AARRR) and extra conventional measures like system usability scale (SUS), none sticks higher than the HEART metric.

But, I firmly consider we will nonetheless do higher as designers. Though it has helped us begin with capturing vital outcomes, there are points in its method, as shared by a couple of critics.

1. Happiness (H) is daring however problematic as the primary success metric.

To guide with happiness first is a extremely desired end result, however not a sensible one. Not solely are feelings subjective, they’re meaningless too. I could say that I’m comfortable or upset, however my actions could not point out in any other case. As Anthropologist Margaret Mead put it,

“What folks say, what folks do, and what they are saying they do are fully various things.”

Putting happiness at the beginning of the framework can also be moderately unconventional. As one other saying goes, “Placing the cart earlier than the horse” means doing one thing within the incorrect order or out of the pure sequence of occasions. On this state of affairs, how can we measure happiness earlier than the precise utilization? Maybe that is why notion metrics are sometimes on the finish of any expertise.

2. Likewise, putting process success (T) on the finish after retention is counterintuitive

The gradual build-up of engagement (E), adoption (A), and retention (R) creates a powerful, lasting measure that may resonate with even non-designers. Nonetheless, positioning process success (T) because the epitomal second does appear to fall wanting being a better end result than retention.

Paradoxically, wouldn’t there be process successes alongside each a part of the framework? Eradicating process success virtually implies denying its presence elsewhere, which isn’t correct.

3. Then there are objectives, alerts, and metrics (GSM)

Upon nearer inspection, they’re fairly much like John Doerr’s Goal and Key Outcomes (OKR). Doerr launched this philosophy to Google’s founders in 1999 at a ping-pong desk that doubled as a boardroom desk. Due to this fact, except for a potential evolution from OKR to GSM, there isn’t a compelling purpose to vary an efficient technique within the company world if it’s merely a reputation change.

4. Besides perhaps a brand new identify ought to be the case.

Reminiscence serves us higher when a catchy acronym pertains to its key actions. That is by far essentially the most compelling issue that many UX practitioners bear in mind about Google’s HEART framework. Simply considering of a coronary heart brings to thoughts a pink, common form with two arches on the prime and a pointy backside. Together with a recognisable analysis publication and Google as a model, that is essentially why the HEART has been so profitable. However is it?

Consuming endlessly to our coronary heart’s need is feasible if all is properly. Sadly, count on 2024 to be the primary yr to exceed 1.5°C above pre-industrial ranges for a lot of the yr. Secretary-Common of the World Meteorological Organisation, Celeste Saulo, made the next feedback about latest occasions:

“The record-breaking rainfall and flooding, quickly intensifying tropical cyclones, lethal warmth, relentless drought, and raging wildfires that we now have seen in several components of the world this yr are sadly our new actuality and a foretaste of our future.”

And but, we had seen comparable patterns from a long time earlier. Tracing the foundation trigger behind local weather change, one would say it’s largely because of our insatiable consumption tradition. What’s worse is that, as designers, we’re accountable for our capacity to create the hedonistic treadmill of need. Sustainability pioneer Victor papanek as soon as stated,

“Promoting design, in persuading folks to purchase issues they don’t want, with cash they don’t have, with the intention to impress others who don’t care, might be the phoniest subject in existence right now.”

What if I say there may be really a approach to make a change, such that it requires a couple of small tweaks to the present HEART framework? Let’s face it, not all ought to go to waste. As a substitute, we might retain some very robust factors and additional reinforce them with the next modifications:

1. Begin with a transparent, unmistakable imaginative and prescient.

A imaginative and prescient surpasses any purpose or goal. And when linked to values and ideas, imaginative and prescient gives an invisible momentum that drives the need for optimistic change. Jim Collins reveals the three primary parts to a imaginative and prescient:

1. a corporation’s elementary purpose for existence past simply getting cash (typically referred to as its mission or goal)
2. its timeless, unchanging core values
3. big and audacious — however in the end achievable — aspirations for its personal future

As soon as we now have the weather, the following step could be to decide on a greater imaginative and prescient. Miraculously, shifting the H in HEART proper to the again of the acroymn kinds a extra significant phrase—EARTH, and what higher approach than to recollect the one spaceship we’re at present residing on?

Add a couple of extra strains to substantiate what your design or actions imply to the planet. For instance, is what you might be designing going to assist Earth ecologically, increase social fairness, or present new worth to all shareholders, together with nature?

2. Double down on measurable behaviours that present varied types of currencies

In contrast to happiness, which tends to return as opinions from fast surveys, currencies present tangible proof of metrics. This offers you the peace of mind that your efforts are certainly paying off.

So what’s a forex? Whereas we frequently consider forex as cash, which is undeniably a strong medium, there are many different currencies, similar to time, info, and energy. (such theories should not new, as Lean Startup creator Eric Ries additional particulars)

To place it one other approach, these efforts and time can scale back conventional processing prices. Plus, with correct information safety and consent, you possibly can trade info for one thing precious.

Nonetheless, simply as vital is the behavioural response that comes with the forex. This can be a excellent alternative to conduct UX analysis to raised perceive the connection between the consumer and their digital life-style or to conduct product testing to see if what they use will finally fall throughout the EARTH framework. By observing and interviewing, or by offering design diaries for them to report throughout a time frame, designers might establish the patterns early on with out making wild guesses on the later levels.

3. Change Process success (T) with Whole returns (T)

As a substitute of viewing profitable process completion as the final word purpose, let’s elevate the idea by specializing in returns. In monetary companies, a return is the revenue you achieve from an funding. This ought to be a key measure as a result of it displays prospects’ willingness to pay for added advantages.

Moreover, returns give a way of placing one thing again to it’s authentic state. What higher approach to acknowledge the return of Earth’s sources, particularly when they’re on the finish of their lifecycle? If we do not responsibly flow into our output, some byproducts will solely additional injury the local weather.

We will be custodians of accountable returns by designing our merchandise with the next measures:

1. Carbon credit to income ratio 
2. % of optimistic power generated from web optimistic buildings 
3. Biodiversity conversion from profitable gross sales 
4. Round useful resource ratio 
5. In the direction of a Zero landfill operation 
6. Water replenishment objectives 
7. Reforestation efforts with variety of timber planted 
8. % of gross sales given again to Earth 
9. Product takeback charges 
10. Common product lifespan

4. And lastly, measure Happiness (H) on the finish to find out whether or not the actions taken by the consumer are memorable

Drawing from Daniel Kahneman’s remembering self principle, we will measure happiness after an expertise by counting on our reminiscences to establish the most effective and worst components of our design journey. We are able to additionally analyse and examine whether or not the opposite metrics alongside EARTH relate to the consumer’s remembering self, utilizing this chance to recall and immediate for additional insights.

Remembering Daniel Kahneman in our UX apply

10 concepts I’ve realized from Pondering Quick and Sluggish

The web promoter rating, which measures a buyer’s willingness to suggest an expertise to new customers, can also be associated to happiness. This completes the cycle of happiness, bringing the EARTH framework into play for each repeated and new customers from suggestions. Over time, these actions convey us nearer to realising the imaginative and prescient of complete returns, with Earth as a serious shareholder in our designs.

---

The HEART framework revolutionised UX design by specializing in happiness and engagement, however it’s time for an improve. The EARTH framework introduces sustainability and tangible returns, urging designers to rethink priorities and metrics. By embracing this alteration, we will design for a greater future—each for customers and the planet.

References

Collins, J. (2000, June). Jim Collins — Articles — Aligning Motion and Values. Www.jimcollins.com. https://www.jimcollins.com/article_topics/articles/aligning-action.html

Doerr, J. (2018). Measure What Issues. Penguin.

Ries, E. (2009). Enterprise ecology and the 4 buyer currencies. Startuplessonslearned.com. https://www.startuplessonslearned.com/2009/12/business-ecology-and-four-customer.html

Rodden, Okay., Hutchinson, H., & Fu, X. (2010). Measuring the consumer expertise on a big scale. Proceedings of the twenty eighth Worldwide Convention on Human Elements in Computing Techniques — CHI ’10, 2010. https://doi.org/10.1145/1753326.1753687

World Meteorological Group. (2024, November 8). 2024 is on observe to be hottest yr on report as warming quickly hits 1.5°C. World Meteorological Group. https://wmo.int/information/media-centre/2024-track-be-hottest-year-record-warming-temporarily-hits-15degc